What Readers are saying

Based on 486 reviews
93%
(452)
5%
(25)
2%
(8)
0%
(1)
0%
(0)
Remember Mail you enjoy?

I didn’t, either! So nice to get some now. From the vintage font reminiscent of my first typewriter to an engrossing story that leaves you eager for the next envelope, I’m so glad I took a chance on Scare Mail! Do yourself a favor and give the gift of peeking in the mailbox with a feeling of hope!

A
ScareMail - Scare.Me
Alexander K.

I’m scared of it. I want to unsubscribe !

Fantastic

We’ve just begun this journey, and we’re already engrossed in our second letter. Each word is a delight, expertly crafted to capture our imaginations and hold us in thrall. The intrigue has completely captivated us, leaving us on the edge of our seats, eager to unravel the unfolding mystery. The anticipation for the next letter is almost palpable; we can hardly contain our excitement as we await its arrival next week. It’s truly remarkable how such a well-written piece can spark such enthusiasm and curiosity within us.

I purchased as a gift and they love it!

CHILLS AND THRILLS

I am a new subscriber to scaremail and have only received my first letter thus far and boy can I say I am already hooked. From the first page of the 3 page letter, the story pulls you in and keeps you wanting more. I am sov excited for this reading journey and Love Love Love that you guys are bringing back old school reading. Thank you to everyone on your team.

A New Favorite

These stories are a nice quick read and the characters are interesting. They have some very unique stories that I haven’t read before. I own all of Stephen King and Dean Koontz books and might just have to add this author to my collection!

Story

I am thoroughly enjoying the story so much and I love how all the letters end leaving you like to think what is going to happen. Can't wat for the next letter to arrive it's going to be awesome!

Great Gift!

I bought this as a gift for a friend and they love it so far!

ScareMail - Scare.Me

Intriguing

I am only 2 letters in, but this journey so far has captured my interest! I am so excited to continue reading my letters after receiving them in the mail. Having to wait and have my excitement grow is an old school feeling that is fun to have again!

Invested!

Hi! I only got two letters so far since I started this journey, and just off the two letters I've gotten I'm already invested and get antsy waiting for the next one that comes! ❣️Highly recommend doing this! It's very refreshing to do something like this it's different it's fun it'll kept you on your toes and wanting more!!

The Suspense Is Killing Me... In A Good Way

I love the anticipation of waiting for the next letter! I'm intrigued, and some what freaked out as I've received two letters and they have already broached the topic of my second worst fear. It's almost as if the author truly knows what I'm afraid of.

Really cool

Great storytelling and I like the extra stuff that comes in the mail

Great story and waiting for next letter to arrive… my wife and I read them during coffee in the morning

Great so far

I'm really enjoying the story so far. I'm only 2 letters in and am excited for more!

I’ve only got the first two letters so far. I can’t review yet.

I’m giving a 5 right now because the anticipation I feel waiting for these letters is great. It’s such a fun and unique way to tell a story. But I’ve only gotten the first two so far. It’s a good introduction but I don’t know enough to really review it yet. Please send me this review near the end of the year long stretch. I’ll be better prepared. For now though I’ll give you a five.

#
ScareMail - Scare.Me
#theheavymetalmom
Best Self Care Gift Ever!

I love horror, heavy metal, camping, concerts, blind boxes, surprises, Edward Lee books, vintage and....Scaremail. Hands down the best gift I've ever lifted myself...and my mom! Forever fan, #theheavymetalmom

Wasn't even for me.

I actually purchased 3 of the scaremail year long letter story's for 3 woman. They all love them an anxiously await every letter.

A nice experience

Incredible

It's honestly hard to stop reading and wanting to know more

Intriguing

I, rather impatiently, wait on the edge of me seat for each new letter to arrive. I can't wait to see where this story goes, being impatient it feels slow but thats all part of the experience. The design of the envelope is unique and I know exactly what it is without having to read anything.

Great price for the bundle and easy to acces EBooks. So excited to get started!

Perfect companion

The box is the perfect companion to the Scare.Me. I love the novel cover appearance and it came signed!!! An added bonus we did not expect. It looks great on the rest of my horror shelf

C
ScareMail - Scare.Me
Christina A.
The Wanting

I absolutely love ScareMail!! I want more spooky and grotesque but each letter I find myself wanting more. With each letter I receive I think I know the direction it could possibly be going in, then I get the next letter and it completely throws that out the window. I love that this keeps throwing the reader through loops. I find myself checking my mailbox frequently hoping my next scare mail letter is inside.

ScareMail - Scare.Me